Singapore Democrats

Home News Singapore More contradictions from LKY over immigration policy
More contradictions from LKY over immigration policy Print Email
Thursday, 09 February 2012
Singapore Democrats

The SDP reported on this website the staggering contradictions made by the PAP Government over the foreign-workers' policy. Over a period of less than two years, the authorities swung from wanting to reduce the number of foreigners coming into Singapore to increasing it. (See here)

This can perhaps be traced to Mr Lee Kuan Yew who no one doubts still wields instrumental influence in the Government even though he is officially not a member of the cabinet.

Recently, in his Lunar New Year speech at the Tanjong Pagar GRC, he insisted that Singaporeans accept his party's policy of encouraging the mass immigration of foreign workers to Singapore.

This is, to a large degree, not surprising as Mr Lee has been championing the current immigration policy since it was first mooted. In January 2011, he repeated that “we need young immigrants. Otherwise our economy will slow down”. For good measure, he added, “like the Japanese economy.” (See here)

A year earlier, however, he averred that, “We've grown in the last five years by just importing labour. Now, the people feel uncomfortable, there are too many foreigners. Trains are overcrowded with foreigners, buses too, property prices have gone up because foreigners with permanent residence are buying into the market.” (See here)

His solution? “We check the flow of foreigners, raise your productivity, do the job better, so that instead of two workers, eventually you'll do it with one worker...” Then he added: “Like the Japanese do.”

Within a period of 12 months, Mr Lee swung from pointing out the problems of an overcrowded city and pledging to reduce the number of foreigners in Singapore to adamantly insisting that we need yet more foreign workers.

And in both instances, he cited the Japanese experience. To make his case for more foreign workers, he said that Japan was an ageing society and hence needed an infusion of young immigrants.

To make his other case for less foreign workers, he noted that Japan had limited the intake of foreigners which raised the productivity of the Japanese workforce.

With clarity like this, who needs confusion?

More than confusion, however, Mr Lee's contradictions signal a deeper problem for Singaporeans. The former Minister Mentor's remarks are reflected in the Government's current muddle-headedness over the immigration policy. They betray a lack of certainty by the PAP on how we should proceed into the future.

Given the Government's lack of clarity, should we not slowdown the process and thoroughly investigate the economic, social and political ramifications before rushing to bring in so many people onto this island?

The SDP has repeatedly warned that if such a policy fails, the consequences will be catastrophic. Singaporeans should be very worried.

Share this article:
Facebook Technorati Stumble It! Newsvine Reddit Del.icio.us Digg This!
Comments (3)
  • komodo
    LKY plan is simple. After he came to power his intention was to stay in office forever, helped along by his son and his grandsons. The trick is how to do it. After eliminating all his old guard, he made sure no one with talent is admitted to the PAP. Hence you cannot just join the PAP. You have to be screened and invited. If LKY says no, you have had it. Then he made sure the locals cannot vote for someone he dislikes. Now he institutes his birth control policy that was so effective it reduced the number of births from 62000 to 30000. Now there will never be enough locals to vote against him. Now he can bring in foreigners, who have no stake in Singapore. They come, earn money and "chabut" back to their own country. Along the way he put his critics in jail or bankrupted them. This is infinitely better than putting them to the death. In Singapore if you are penniless you are condemned to a living death. Worse than the real thing. What do you see now? His ministers are so soft( so "lembeh") and so unaccomplished that when you see them talk if parliament you want to cry. What a scenerio!
  • quantum
    He cannot stay in office forever. It breaks the laws of biology.
  • Tan Tai Wei
    "komodo", He did not mean to do what you describe. But you might well be right that something of the kind has been the consequence of what He did!
Please login or register to post your comments.
 

Act Now

Please Donate
More options to donate
 

The SDP National Healthcare Plan

SDP Publictaions

Magazine Support SDP , buy our 30th Anniversary Magazine here


                        pdf link

minsal
pdf
link

 

Danny the Democracy Bear

Now available online here!

 
Banner
Banner

Awesome Words

What shall it profit a man if he gains the whole world but loses his soul.

Jesus Christ
Banner

News feeds

Singapore Democrat News
Joomla Templates by JoomlaShack