Siriporn Chanjindamanee and Petchanet Pratruangkrai
18 Oct 06
Loss of $850m predicted – if buyer can be found, that is
Singapore state investment firm Temasek Holdings stands to lose more than Bt20 billion if it were to sell off its controversial majority holding in Shin Corp, financial experts believe.
Brokerage analysts said Temasek, which controls about 96 per cent of Shin Corp, might have to sell up to 47 per cent of the company, or 1.5 billion shares, to resolve the foreign ownership dispute.
Thai law restricts foreign interests in Thai firms to below 50 per cent, so Temasek must reduce its holding by 47 per cent to meet the 49 per cent limit.
The 47 per cent stake in Shin Corp is now worth a market price of Bt52.32 billion, compared with Bt74.14 billion in January this year – a loss for Temasek of more than Bt20 billion.
On Monday, Temasek issued a statement to clarify its willingness to reduce its holding in Shin Corp at an appropriate time to ensure an orderly market. However, it has not yet addressed the question of whether it breached Thai law by allegedly relying on nominees to take over Shin Corp.
A fund manager said Temasek might want to complete the share sale in November, before a court verdict on whether to revoke the licences of Shin Corp subsidiaries due to Temasek’s alleged violation of foreign ownership law.
But other analysts believe Temasek might find it very difficult to find potential buyers.
“Temasek is looking for potential buyers but it may not be able to conclude the deal by November because it involves lots of money,” said an analyst.
He said only a handful of Thai companies such as Siam Cement, Charoen Pokphand (CP) and Thai Beverage Plc have enough cash to acquire the Shin Corp stake.
However, Thai Beverage is unlikely to buy Shin Corp shares because its chairman Charoen Sirivadhanabhakdi is reluctant to get involved in political issues. CP is also unlikely to spend a huge amount of money on such a move, said the source.
Now, the focus is on Siam Cement and Siam Commercial Bank (SCB), both partially owned by the Crown Property Bureau. But the source quoted a senior official at Government House as saying Siam Cement or Siam Commercial Bank’s buying into Shin Corp “could never happen”.
SCB has an indirect interest in Shin Corp, but Khunying Jada Wattanasiritham, the bank’s president and CEO, said “there’s no reason for SCB to buy more Shin Corp shares”.
Korn Chatikavanij, deputy secretary-general of the Democrat Party, also discounted the possibility of Temasek finding any Thai buyer for its Shin Corp stake in the near future.
“Who would want to step in now? There are several contentious legal problems surrounding Shin Corp. Not to mention the case against Shin Corp at the Administrative Court,” he said.
Temasek bought 49 per cent of Shin Corp from the Shinawatra and Damapong families in January this year. In a subsequent public tender for the remaining shares Temasek, through Cedar Holdings and Aspen Holdings, snapped up almost everything and ended up controlling 96 per cent of the Thai company, leaving just 4 per cent as a free float.
Temasek’s senior managing director Jimmy Phoon said in a statement on Monday the share reduction plan was part of his company’s original intention, to maintain Shin Corp’s listing status on the Thai stock market following Temasek’s public tender offer in March. But he did not say how many shares it planned to sell to keep the stocks liquid in the market.
Seamico Securities Plc said the sale was inevitable. It predicted Temasek might have to sell 51 per cent to reduce the risk from the nominee controversy.
An analyst from Asia Credit Securities said Phoon’s announcement was good news. “It should promote the free float of Shin Corp shares on the market and reduce foreign investors’ worries on the future operation of Shin Corp,” he said.
Local telecom operator Advanced Info Service (AIS) has 48.3 per cent of its shares held by foreigners. If foreign shareholders in Shin Corp are included, the foreign stake in AIS would be 91.1 per cent, much higher than the legal limit of 49 per cent.
“If Temasek wants to reduce Shin’s foreign shareholders to 49 per cent, it has to sell around 1.547 billion shares,” the analyst said.
“Now we have to see if Temasek sells the shares to institutional investors or to retail investors. And what will the conditions be for the sale,” he queried.
Meanwhile Karun Kittisataporn, permanent secretary of the Commerce Ministry, said in spite of Temasek’s intention to sell its stake, the ministry will continue with its legal action to follow up the Business Development Department’s investigation on whether Kularb Kaew is a nominee of Temasek.
“It was a separate issue. The ministry will proceed with the case,” he said.
Last month, the ministry concluded its investigation, finding that Kularb Kaew was a nominee of Temasek Holdings. The case was handed over to Tung-Mahamek police station. In the primary investigation, the department found it likely Kularb Kaew was in breach of the kingdom’s Foreign Business Act.